Funny & Ticklish Surgical Strike
By M K Bhadrakumar – October 2, 2016
The Indian journalists must be compulsorily made to read the parting speech by Helen Boaden, Director of BBC Radio, as she resigned from her position last weekend, on how the scramble for ‘breaking news’ is degrading and destroying what used to be a wonderful profession. She valiantly makes a case for ‘slow news’. (Independent)
At issue here is the Indian media coverage of our “surgical strikes” across the Line of Control at Pakistan on September 29. India has been whipped into frenzy by the media. What happened is not good for health – of individuals or of the nation. Fortunately, Finance Minister Arun Jaitley interjected with perfect timing to take the mind away to the exciting vista of the “biggest disclosure” in independent India’s history by tax-evading crooks.
But that crime thriller can make the “surgical strikes” go away only momentarily. According to news from Islamabad, a top aide to PM Narendra Modi contacted a key figure on Friday to convey to PM Nawaz Sharif India’s desire not to ‘escalate’. But then, Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar promptly undercut Modi the very next day by just recalled the Caesarean section by India to take out the little Bangladeshi infant out of the Pakistani womb. So, Jaitley is passe.
The war is wide open, again. Parrikar must be pleased with himself. In fact, he is only being true to himself. Remember his famous statement in June last year that the people of India were losing respect for the Indian Army, because it no longer fought wars? (DNA)
Meanwhile, the “surgical strikes” as such remain an enigma wrapped in mystery. The government has officially stated very little on the actual operation. Almost the entire Indian media coverage is based on off-the-record briefings or hearsay, or, worse still, the fiery imagination of journalists.Spin doctors had a whale of a time.
Two things must be said about Indian Army: one, it takes the business of war very seriously and will not make exaggerated claims; and, two, it is very precise with words. Especially so, the office of Director-General of Military Operations (DGMO), the transcripts of whose conversations with Pakistani counterparts I have had occasion to read in their dozens while heading the Pakistan Division in the Ministry of External Affairs.
However, in his entire presentation on September 29, DGMO Lt. Gen. Ranbir Singh actually said nothing to corroborate what the media reported. And he read out from a prepared text.
Troubling questions arise.
Not a single American lawmaker – and there could be quite a few who are within the orbit of Indian embassy’s influence – has spoken specifically about our “surgical strikes”. They only speak about India’s commitment to counterterrorism. These are of course Congressmen who are willing to speak up for India in real time, rain or sunshine. Why are they so aloof?
The US state department briefings too neatly sidestepped our “surgical strikes” and stuck to old mantras — supreme importance of India-Pakistan engagement, etc. Nor did the White House readout on the conversation between NSA Susan Rice and her Indian counterpart Ajit Doval make reference to “surgical strikes”. (One could argue, perhaps, Doval couldn’t be expected to disclose beforehand an imminent James Bond-style operation, but then, Rice represents Washington’s ‘defining partnership’ with Modi government.)
To be sure, Americans have positioned military satellites above India that could spot a bat flying in the dark. And they must be knowing what exactly happened.
Again, Russians too have advanced capabilities. In fact, a Russian army contingent is conducting exercises in Pakistan. Yet, Russian official media tiptoed around our “surgical strikes”. The RT report pointedly noted, “He (DGMO Ranbir Singh) did not elaborate on the nature of the operations, or whether Indian troops had entered Pakistani territory.”
There were no references to our “surgical strikes” by the FO spokeswoman in Moscow, either. Maria Zakharova, in her briefing on September 29, touched on 12 different topics and took thirteen questions, but there was no take on “surgical strikes”.
Now, the unkindest cut of all is that United Nations Secretary-General Ban Ki Moon’s spokesman disclosed in New York on Saturday that the UN Military Observer Group in India and Pakistan “has not directly observed any firing across the LOC related to the latest incident (of September 29)”. We simply stonewalled the UN’s remark.
It is all becoming rather murky. In the absence of authoritative statements, Pakistani version gains the upper hand — namely, that there were no “surgical strikes” and that Indians simply hyped up artillery exchanges and are hiding heavy casualties.
Perhaps, MEA spokesman could at least contest the Pakistani version factually. It’s anyway ‘slow news’ already, as Helen Boaden put it.
- HRW urges Jordan to deny entry or arrest Sudan’s Bashir March 26, 2017Bashir accused of war crimes in Darfur conflict by ICC The post HRW urges Jordan to deny entry or arrest Sudan’s Bashir appeared first on The Express Tribune.AFP
- FC foils terror bid in Balochistan March 26, 2017Recovers, diffuses IED planted to disrupt census process on Turbat-Dasht road The post FC foils terror bid in Balochistan appeared first on The Express Tribune.News Desk
- Iran to sanction 15 US companies for Israel ties March 26, 2017US announced new sanctions against groups and individuals it accuses of collaborating with Iran's weapons programme The post Iran to sanction 15 US companies for Israel ties appeared first on The Express Tribune.AFP
- K-P govt claims major improvement in schools, IMU disagrees March 26, 2017The report says asserts that 6 per cent of school in the province lack sanitation The post K-P govt claims major improvement in schools, IMU disagrees appeared first on The Express Tribune.Asad Zia
- PM to visit Hyderabad on Monday March 26, 2017Nawaz Sharif will address a public gathering, hold party meetings The post PM to visit Hyderabad on Monday appeared first on The Express Tribune.News Desk
- Sweden hotel offers refund, only if you divorce March 26, 2017The offer is open to all couples "legally married and staying in the same room" The post Sweden hotel offers refund, only if you divorce appeared first on The Express Tribune.AFP
- 4th Test: India escape Aussie pacers, fall to Lyon March 26, 2017Veteran spinner’s late wickets break hosts’ resistance The post 4th Test: India escape Aussie pacers, fall to Lyon appeared first on The Express Tribune.AFP
- Terror bid foiled as security forces recover arms’ cache in N Waziristan March 26, 2017The recovered ammunition included rockets of various types, rocket-propellers and anti-tank bullets The post Terror bid foiled as security forces recover arms’ cache in N Waziristan appeared first on The Express Tribune.Our Correspondent
- Netherlands in danger of missing out on qualification March 26, 20172-0 defeat to Bulgaria leaves European giants battling against tide to feature in 2018 World Cup The post Netherlands in danger of missing out on qualification appeared first on The Express Tribune.AFP
- This new supersonic passenger jet will cut travel times by half March 26, 2017The XB-1 or 'Baby Boom' jet will be capable of flying from London to New York in just three hours and 15 minutes The post This new supersonic passenger jet will cut travel times by half appeared first on The Express Tribune.Tech Desk
- HRW urges Jordan to deny entry or arrest Sudan’s Bashir March 26, 2017
- Cities and monuments switch off for Earth HourPARIS: Iconic global monuments including the Eiffel Tower, the Kremlin, the Acropolis in Athens and Sydney´s Opera House plunged into darkness Saturday to mark Earth Hour and draw attention to climate change. Millions of people from some 170 countries and territories are expected to take part in the annual bid to highlight global warming caused by […]
- China working closely with Pakistan on CPEC: SpokespersonBEIJING: A spokesman of Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs said that China stood ready to work with Pakistan to move forward the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) so as to benefit the peoples of the two countries. “The CPEC is a new cooperation framework set up by China and Pakistan to pursue long-term development. It is […]
- 'Madhu Lal Hussain's 429th annual 3-day Urs startsLAHORE: Shah Hussain, popularly known as Madhu Lal Hussain's 429th annual three day festival started in Lahore on Saturday. A large number of devotees from around the country visited the shrine of Madhu Lal Hussain to pay tributes to the Sufi poet and his close friend. Mehfil-e-Samaa and Mehfil-e-Naat would be held in which renowned […]
- Pakistan allows Raheel Sharif to head Saudi allianceISLAMABAD: Pakistan government has formally permitted ex-army chief Gen Raheel Sharif (retd) to lead Saudi military alliance to fight militancy, Defence Minister Khawaja Asif told Geo News anchor Saleem Safi. The complete interview of Khawaja Asif in Geo News programme Jirga would be telecast tonight. Former army chief’s Saudi assignment to lead Islamic Military Alliance […]
- Aizaz Chaudhry says dialogues, political stability only solution to Afghan issueWASHINGTON: Pakistan’s new Ambassador to United States, Aizaz Ahmad Chaudhry has stated that Operation Raddul Fasaad was initiated to eliminate the remnants of terrorists. Speaking to US journalists here, Aizaz Chaudhry said, “Military operation Zarb-e-Azb has yielded positive results. Raddul Fasaad is launched to eliminate the remnants of terrorists.” Over Pak-India relations, Aizaz Chaudhry said […]
- Cities and monuments switch off for Earth Hour
- A Sikh Man Was Harassed In Pakistan And What Happened Next Was Totally Unexpected! by parhlo.com March 25, 2017
- Pakistan Day 23 March, 2017 March 22, 2017
- Holy well: ‘Water held sacred by Sikhs to be exported’ March 22, 2017
- Fraud Charity Muslim Hands:Charity trustee Mohammed Ashfaq who misused funds and took a massive salary March 22, 2017
- ENCOURAGING FEEDBACK ON SIKH FEDERATION (UK) ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING by Sardar Gurjeet Singh, National Press Secretary, Sikh Federation (UK) March 20, 2017